Wishing Well
📍 79 High St, Mexborough S64 9AB, UK
About Wishing Well
The Wishing Well is a popular and highly-rated cafe situated on High Street in Mexborough. Boasting an impressive Google rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, it's a firm favourite among locals and visitors alike for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious, well-priced meals. Guests often praise the friendly and quick service, making for a pleasant dining experience.
Open for both breakfast and dinner, the cafe offers a varied menu that caters to different tastes, from hearty morning meals to satisfying evening fare. The team at Wishing Well are known for going the extra mile, with reviews highlighting their exceptional service, including thoughtful touches like offering water for furry friends. It’s a place where quality food meets genuine hospitality.
Visiting Information
Wishing Well is open Monday to Saturday from 8:00 AM to 3:00 PM, and closed on Sundays. Please note that information regarding payment options is not available. The premises do not offer wheelchair accessible parking or entrance.
Location
Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
📍 79 High St, Mexborough S64 9AB, UK
from 109 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 109 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 7 February 2026.
Just had a chicken dinner . Cost £8 n they must have put me on a diet, a child's portion would be better. So small . Won't be coming back. Unless the meal is bigger
Very friendly and quick service
Wow this cafe is absolutely amazing. Me and my partner and 2 boys went twice today for breakfast and dinner. The service is out of this world they offered water for my puppy, the food was amazing and well priced. Everyone there was so lovely and an experience that I won't forget in a hurry, we will definitely be back. Thank you 😊 Kevin, Gillian, Elliot and Thomas and Milo 🐕 🐾
Been here twice. Food was nice had breakfast was very big plate for size amount of food. They put bread on same plate bit strange as gets all greasy and other things like egg. I prefer my bread on different plate but if you take off the bread then plate was too empty for food amount. I would recommend small plate for breakfast and side plate for bread or toast. Spoiled it for me
Had steak pie chips and mushy peas, not much meat in the pie but the pastry more than made up for it, was microwaved but if you leave it long enough it’s ok, didn’t like the chips much, they could have been much better, the peas were ok, nothing special. The staff were pleasant and talkative apart from the teenage female who seemed incapable of smiling and interacting, all in all the highlight was the interaction with the staff and the nice pastry which was the major part of the pie.