Welcome to Yorkshire
News • August 5th, 2026
|A recent study has revealed that a staggering 70% of consumers are unable to distinguish between marketing materials created by artificial intelligence (AI) and those crafted by human designers. This finding highlights how advanced AI technology has become, making it increasingly difficult for people to tell the difference between machine-generated content and human creativity.
Research Findings
The research, conducted by instantprint and involving 2,000 participants, explored whether consumers could identify the origins of various marketing assets. Participants were shown a range of summer-themed marketing materials, including posters, flyers, and social media advertisements, and were asked to determine if each piece was created by a human or a machine. The results were surprising, as only 12% of respondents correctly identified all of the AI-generated campaigns presented to them. Key findings from the study include:
70% of consumers failed to correctly identify AI-generated marketing materials.
Only 12% successfully identified every AI-generated campaign.
72% of business owners and marketers have used AI for marketing materials in the past year.
63% reported saving at least three hours each week on marketing tasks due to AI.
52% said AI enables them to create more marketing content than before.
38% experienced issues printing AI-generated artwork due to quality or formatting problems.
These findings illustrate the growing reliance on AI within the marketing sector. As businesses continue to adopt AI tools, they are discovering both benefits and challenges associated with this technology.
AI in Marketing
The rise of AI in marketing has been substantial, with many businesses integrating AI tools into their strategies. Nearly three-quarters of respondents reported using AI to enhance their marketing efforts over the last year. This shift is not just about saving time; it's also about increasing productivity. Many businesses are now able to produce more content than ever before, ensuring they maintain a consistent presence across various platforms, such as social media, email, and print. Despite the advantages, there remains a public perception that associates creativity and originality more strongly with human designers. This suggests that while AI can assist in generating content, it is still essential for human creativity and strategic thinking to play a vital role in marketing.
Challenges with AI-Generated Artwork
While AI-generated designs can be impressive, businesses face challenges when it comes to printing these materials. The study found that 38% of business owners who used AI-generated artwork encountered quality issues, such as low-resolution images and colour inconsistencies. Additionally, many users were unaware of important technical requirements for professional printing, such as CMYK colour settings, which are crucial for achieving the best results in print production. As a result, businesses must navigate these challenges carefully to ensure their marketing materials look as good in print as they do on screen.
Expert Insights
Craig Wassell, Marketing Manager at instantprint, shared insights on the implications of these findings:
"The conversation around AI often focuses on whether machines will replace designers, but our findings suggest that's not what businesses are using the technology for. Most organisations are embracing AI because it helps them save time, generate ideas, and create marketing content more efficiently."
"What's particularly interesting is how difficult consumers now find it to distinguish between AI-generated and human-created marketing materials. The technology has improved dramatically in a very short period of time, and we’re reaching a point where visual quality alone is no longer a reliable indicator."
Recommendations for Businesses
To maximise the benefits of AI-generated marketing materials, instantprint offers several recommendations for businesses:
Use AI as a supportive tool rather than a complete replacement for human creativity.
Review all AI-generated artwork before publishing or printing.
Ensure images are high enough resolution for their intended use.
Check colour settings and file formats prior to sending artwork to print.
Combine AI-generated ideas with human input to enhance creativity and maintain brand consistency.
As AI technologies continue to evolve, the future of marketing will likely see a blend of human creativity and machine efficiency. The most successful businesses will be those that learn to effectively integrate AI into their marketing strategies while retaining the unique insights and creativity that human designers bring to the table.
