The Secret Italian
📍 McLintock Way, Barnsley S70 6BF, UK
About The Secret Italian
The Secret Italian is a highly-rated culinary gem nestled in Barnsley, offering an authentic taste of Italy. With an impressive 4.8/5-star Google rating from over 250 reviews, this restaurant is celebrated for its delicious food and inviting atmosphere. It’s often described by diners as a true 'secret gem', known for its intimate and friendly setting that promises a memorable dining experience.
Specialising in exquisite Italian cuisine, The Secret Italian has garnered praise for its exceptional dishes and the warm hospitality provided by the team. Customer reviews consistently highlight the 10/10 quality of the food and the accommodating nature of the staff. Due to its popularity, advance booking is highly recommended, as the restaurant often books up months in advance, securing its reputation as a must-visit dining destination in Yorkshire.
Visiting Information
The Secret Italian welcomes diners Wednesday to Saturday, from 7:00 PM to 10:00 PM. Please note the restaurant is closed on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Sundays. Accessibility features are not specified at this time. For your convenience, the restaurant accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC payments.
Location
Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
📍 McLintock Way, Barnsley S70 6BF, UK
from 253 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 253 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 5 February 2026.
We managed to get a last minute booking due to a cancellation for my dad’s birthday and I couldn’t be happier. I’ve been trying to get a booking for ages so I was thrilled that we got this! The staff were so accommodating and quick to respond. When we got into the restaurant we were told how it works (we all eat together and what the courses were). The BYOB is such a great idea and we were even given a wine cooler for our bottle. Food was gorgeous, especially the pasta dish and the tiramisu which were to die for! All-in-all we will definitely come back again, I can imagine it’s even better in the summer. Thanks again Secret Italian 💕
Would 100% recommend this Italian restaurant, after being recommended by a friend we arrived and noticed it is bookings only. We spoken to a lovely lady at the door who lucky managed to squeeze us in after a reservation didn’t turn up. Food and the atmosphere was 10/10 and could not fault anything, staff were lovely. Having autism and ADHD can be difficult to go to new places, especially trying new food but I left feeling at ease. Would definitely recommend this place to anyone. Very much appreciated
This really is a secret gem in Barnsley. A small but very friendly atmosphere, great host and absolutely delicous food. Would highly recommend you book now as they book up months in advance!
Really enjoyed the food, service and atmosphere. It’s £35 for 6-7 courses and it’s bring your own ale so you can bring the best ale and wine. Experience got finished around 2130hrs for us. Would recommend the experience
Our first time here and what a gem of a restaurant, the Valentine's menu was delicious, 6 starters before the main meal and then the desserts. All the food had so many flavours, we were Absolutely stuffed. You won't be disappointed with this Italian. Margaret and Jana are so welcoming. Many thanks Chris & Allison.