
Highgate Bakery
📍 8, Tinsley Centre, Bawtry Rd, Tinsley, Sheffield S9 1UY, UK
About Highgate Bakery
Highgate Bakery is a beloved spot nestled in Sheffield's Tinsley Centre, celebrated for its hearty and fresh sandwiches. This local gem consistently receives high praise from customers, boasting an impressive Google rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars. Known for its traditional 'old school feel' and excellent value, it offers a welcoming stop for locals and visitors alike seeking a satisfying meal.
Customers frequently highlight the bakery's commitment to quality, with particular acclaim for their generously filled roast meat sandwiches, including popular turkey and pork options, all served on fresh breadcakes. Reviewers consistently commend the friendly service provided by the team, ensuring a pleasant experience with every visit. It's an ideal spot for a quick, delicious lunch to grab and go or enjoy on a short break.
Visiting Information
Highgate Bakery operates Monday to Friday, welcoming customers from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM. Please note that the bakery is closed on Saturdays and Sundays. For payment convenience, the establishment accepts major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC payments. It is important to note that wheelchair accessible seating is not available at this location.
Location

Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
📍 8, Tinsley Centre, Bawtry Rd, Tinsley, Sheffield S9 1UY, UK
from 61 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 61 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 7 February 2026.
Proper decent roast Turkey sandwich when I dropped in last month. Had last visited in 2012 when I had a the greatest roast pork sandwich I’d ever had (still doing those at all?!?!). Excellent value. Old school feel, loved it.
Met by a very friendly young man. Had a beautiful sandwich the breadcake was fresh with plenty of filling.
Great prices and great butties! Can’t fault it ! Little gem close to all the works.
One of the best sandwich shop in the tinsley and brinsworth area fair prices and it always tastes nice and fresh with good quality meats and hot pastries and has a decent selection of buns and sweets Never had a bad meal yet
Great food at really decent prices... The large butties are massive - I recommend the Turkey with all the trimmings on a Thursday!