Best Boy Bagels

The best bagels in Sheffield and beyond. The bagels are hand made and boy can you tell. If you buy a filled bagel, they are tasty, the flavour combos are well thought out and boy are the portions generous. The prices are reasonable for what you get which is a mega filed bagel that will fill you up for days. The atmosphere in the shop is great. Always playing great tunes and the decor is so fun, there is always something new to spot. The staff are lovely and super enthusiastic about the bagels and just make it a great place to visit. My only advice is get there early on a weekend so you don’t miss out!!

I stopped by about 10 minutes before closing and really liked the cozy atmosphere — music playing, warm lighting, and you can even watch them make your bagel. Their menu staples are written on the mirror, with weekly specials on the board, which is a fun touch. The lady behind the counter was absolutely lovely and made me feel very welcome. I tried the Best Boys Lox, which was nice but a bit too much for me and didn’t quite hit the spot (I’d rate it 5/10). It’s on the pricier side, but they’re very generous with the fillings, so you definitely get your money’s worth. I definitely want to come back to try their other bagels!

Delicious bagels made fresh every morning. Had the bacon egg and cheese on sesame. Hefty 🥯. Very friendly and accommodating staff, nice atmosphere, love the branding

A treat to visit, an expensive one at that. But I was very happy with my bagel, a special aubergine and smoked tofu creation. Lovely staff too makes a perfect start to a weekend.

I went to best boys bagel. The place is very interesting, a lot of eye catching stuff. I got the lux bagel with hot sauce it’s a 10/10 would go back to get again. The smoked salmon very fresh and tasteful (in my opinion a little salty tho). Overall would recommend