Rustlings Pantry by Two Brothers Deli and Catering

Rustlings Pantry in Sheffield is a highly-rated 'little gem' renowned for its exceptional sandwiches, delicious breakfasts, and friendly service.

Rustlings Pantry by Two Brothers Deli and Catering is a highly-rated eatery nestled in Sheffield, celebrated by customers as a true 'little gem'. Known for exceeding the typical 'sandwich shop' label, this popular spot provides a warm and friendly atmosphere that draws visitors in for its exceptional food and service. With an outstanding Google rating of 4.9/5 stars from over 100 reviews, it's clear why it's a local favourite.

The pantry specialises in mouth-watering sandwiches, with customer favourites including the Reuben and Cuban, alongside fresh salads like the Halloumi Caesar. Beyond lunch, visitors can enjoy delicious and generous breakfasts, praised for their quality and value. The dedicated team at Rustlings Pantry consistently receives accolades for their welcoming and friendly service, ensuring every visit is a pleasant one. They aim to provide a diverse menu that caters to various tastes, all prepared with care.

Visiting Information

Rustlings Pantry operates from Tuesday to Sunday, typically opening from 8:00 AM (9:00 AM Saturday, 10:00 AM Sunday) and closing by 3:00 PM (2:00 PM on weekends). The pantry accepts various convenient payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC payments.

4.9

from 111 reviews

Google Reviews

Reviews from Google Maps.

Showing 5 of 111 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 6 February 2026.

Anonymous

5/5

3 months ago

Amazing sandwiches and service! We had the Reuben and Cuban sandwiches today and both were delicious and very reasonable priced. The brothers are very friendly and welcoming too! Lots more great menu options which we can't wait to try.

Anonymous

5/5

5 months ago

Popped into Rustlings Pantry on Saturday and loved it! I had the Halloumi Caesar Salad and my partner had the Chicken and Chorizo sandwich- both were absolutely delicious. The place has such a warm, friendly vibe and the service was spot on. We'll definitely be back!

Anonymous

5/5

2 weeks ago

The description 'sandwich shop' doesn't do this little gem justice. I visited for breakfast and wasn't disappointed. The guys were very pleasant and friendly and the medium breakfast was deliciously prepared and generous, I'm glad I didn't order the big breakfast as I wouldn't have been able to finish it all. The breakfast includes tea or coffee and I was offered a refill too, very good value for money. The chalkboard menu has an interesting selection of meals and sandwiches all of which are available to dine in or take out. For a smallish place, I was impressed with the imaginative menu on offer. I'll be back to try the Canadian beef sandwich! Breakfast, lunch or sandwiches - you won't regret visiting Rustlings Pantry.

Anonymous

5/5

9 months ago

My wife, daughter and I have just had brunch at the newly opened Rustlings Pantry - by Two Brothers Deli and Catering. We had Sausage cob, full English, Cuban deli sandwich and hand cut chips. All excellent quality and extremely tasty food. My Cuban was delicious, it’s nice to have something different to the norm. The hand cut chips are excellent traditional home style chips. The owners are really nice guys who are friendly and welcoming. We highly recommend Rustlings Pantry by two brothers and will be back.

Anonymous

5/5

9 months ago

Visited here for breakfast as stopping in the nearby area. Very friendly staff, clean and great service. Had a large sausage and bacon sandwich, and was shocked by the size and quantity of filling! Great portions, quality ingredients and fair prices. Would definitely reccomend and visit again!