Pizza on the Square
📍 Old Town Hall, 58-34 Market Pl, Malton YO17 7LW, UK
About Pizza on the Square
Pizza on the Square is a popular restaurant located within the historic Old Town Hall on Market Place in Malton, offering a distinctive dining experience. Housed in a building noted for its unique character, this eatery provides a memorable backdrop for enjoying authentic Italian-style pizzas in the heart of Malton. Visitors consistently rate it highly, achieving an impressive 4.3 out of 5 stars from 189 reviews.
The menu at Pizza on the Square features delicious pizzas praised for their authentic flavour and soft, pillowy dough, reminiscent of those found in Naples. Customers particularly enjoy specialties such as the truffle garlic options and scrumptious truffle Parmesan fries. The establishment is known for its welcoming atmosphere and excellent service, with ample seating available, including an upstairs area for larger groups or busy periods, ensuring a comfortable visit for all.
Visiting Information
Opening Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Friday - Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Accessibility: The venue is fully accessible with wheelchair accessible parking, entrance, and restrooms.
Payment Options: Credit cards, debit cards, and NFC payments are accepted. Please note, cash-only payment is not an option.
Location
Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
📍 Old Town Hall, 58-34 Market Pl, Malton YO17 7LW, UK
from 189 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 189 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 9 February 2026.
The pizzas are nice when they finally arrive but a 45 minute wait for two pizzas is too much, especially when there were lots of empty tables so it wasn’t busy. All the other tables were waiting too, so it wasn’t just us. We were also a bit surprised that everything is served on paper plates. I’m all in favour of compostable plates, but not if they stick to your food. I don’t expect to peel paper off my pizza before I can eat it. On the plus side, it’s dog friendly and was very quiet so we got a table easily.
We stopped here for lunch while our car was changing. What a great location! And the building itself is really nice too. I'm not sure what it used to be, maybe a council building? Lots of character! They had plenty of tables available and more seating upstairs, also the menu looked great, who doesn't like pizza! Plus VEGAN cheese options!! It's order at the bar, and they have a large variety of drinks on offer. We unfortunately got charged extra for our meals but that was sorted out because of miscommunication from the staff. The food was about 20mins wait which wasn't too bad. Nice fresh ingredients, the sauce on the pizza was excellent too. The chips were really hot and crispy too. I would recommend this place if you're in and around Malton.
Great place for a pizza. Just like a real Italian from Napoli. Really enjoyed th service and atmosphere. My family had a ball.
The pizzas are very nice here! The dough was soft and pillowy and the added truffle garlic was delicious. The truffle Parmesan fries were scrumptious too!!
Great vibes and great food! I had the margarita pizza which was super cheesy and filling, the chips as well were very crispy and good value for portion! The staff were very friendly and the service was great! Definitely would go again ✨