The Proper Ice Cream Company
đź“Ť 138 Doncaster Rd, Mexborough S64 0JW, UK
About The Proper Ice Cream Company
The Proper Ice Cream Company is a beloved independent business located in Mexborough, renowned for its exceptional handcrafted ice cream and delicious bakes. With a perfect 5/5 star rating from numerous satisfied customers, this local gem has quickly become a favourite for those seeking a truly indulgent treat.
Visitors can discover a fantastic array of creamy, delicious ice cream flavours, each crafted with care and a commitment to quality that shines through in every scoop. Beyond the incredible ice cream, the company also offers a tempting selection of bakes, praised by customers for their gorgeous taste and excellent value. The dedicated team consistently provides top-quality products and fantastic customer service, ensuring a delightful experience for everyone.
Visiting Information
The Proper Ice Cream Company is open to visitors Thursday and Friday from 1:00 PM to 7:00 PM, and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 1:00 PM. They accept credit cards, debit cards, and NFC payments for your convenience.
Location
Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
đź“Ť 138 Doncaster Rd, Mexborough S64 0JW, UK
from 69 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 69 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 7 February 2026.
Amazing bakes and ice creams. Honestly I’ve never known ice creams to taste this good. Every single flavour ice cream we have tried so far has been incredible. You can tell the owners put their heart and soul into this business with the constantly top quality products they keep putting out. We don’t go anywhere else for our sweet treats and ice cream. Would recommend in a heartbeat to anyone.
So delicious and creamy! It's the best I've cream I've ever eaten. Mint aero, Terry's chocolate orange, milky bar and Kinderella are the best flavours🍦🍫
The bakes are absolutely gorgeous and value for money is amazing! Tegan blows everyone else out for the water and the customer service is great. Thanks for providing such a little town with a brilliant business đź’•
Absolutely amazing ice cream and treat shop!! Never had a bad flavour! This is literally the best ice cream you will ever try!!! Hands down beats any other on the market! It’s creamy it’s fresh and best of all it’s local!! Teagan has absolutely nailed it hands down, her shop is lovely and she’s very welcoming hands down worth a trip just for a tub (or 6)
This is a real gem of a place. I have tried several ice cream flavours over the last few months and look forward to trying more. They have been delicious. Friends and family visiting have agreed. The value for money is great given the quality of ingredients. Compared to supermarket ice creams, it is a different class. I also prefer it to Ben & Jerry’s.