The Cookie Smith

The Cookie Smith in Mexborough offers an incredible range of delectable cookies, cheesecakes, and sweet treats, highly praised by customers.

The Cookie Smith in Mexborough is a celebrated bakery, earning an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars from numerous satisfied customers. Renowned as a go-to spot for exceptional sweet treats, this local gem has quickly become a favourite for those seeking indulgent delights in Yorkshire.

Specialising in an incredible array of cookies and cheesecakes, The Cookie Smith offers products crafted with quality ingredients and praised for their amazing flavour and value. Popular choices include the Cherry Bakewell and Oreo cookies, alongside delicious caramel cheesecakes. The friendly team consistently provides excellent service, contributing to a welcoming experience for all visitors.

Visiting Information

The Cookie Smith is open Wednesday to Saturday, and Sunday afternoons. Customers can visit Wednesday and Thursday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Saturday from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM, and Sunday from 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM. They are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Various payment methods are accepted for convenience.

4.9

from 34 reviews

Google Reviews

Reviews from Google Maps.

Showing 5 of 34 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 7 February 2026.

Anonymous

5/5

4 months ago

Hands down the very best place to get your sweet treat fix!!! The cookies are absolutely amazing! Shout out to the Cherry Bakewell 🤤🤤 Huge range of products but we especially love the caramel cheesecake. Amazing value for money and you can tell they use quality ingredients. Everything has always been fresh, tasty and the service is always on point. We love to support independent businesses but it’s so easy to, when the products are this good! Will forever be a returning customer 🍪🍰

Anonymous

5/5

4 months ago

Best cheesecakes and cookies in the world! 🤤 🤤 Great staff, absolutely love the shop makeover. 💯 recommend anyone to go, just dont be surprised if you put a lb or two on 😆

Anonymous

5/5

3 years ago

Incredible! I can't rate the cookies from Cookie Smith enough. I've bought several cookies and have had an amazing service each time. They arrive on time and taste amazing. They're easily a 10/10 for me! I personally recommend the Cherry Bakewell and Oreo cookies myself

Anonymous

5/5

5 months ago

I dabbled in the cookie smith by buying a slice of cookie pie from my local shop where they supply goodies too. I'd been thinking about it ever since it was that good! Popped in as happened to be driving by and so glad I did! Brownies and cookies are 10/10 would recommend to absolutely everyone. Im glad I dont pass every day or id be in big trouble 😂

Anonymous

5/5

2 years ago

THE BEST COOKIES, thats all there is to it. I've had the pleasure of eating the cookies and cookie pies from these guys since before the shop was open. First saw them at one of their pop-up stalls, which they do at various places (and still do alongside the shop). Go, eat cookies and be happy!