Polly's Cakes.

Polly's Cakes in Otley crafts bespoke, showstopping cakes for all occasions, delighting customers with exquisite designs and flavours.

Polly's Cakes is a highly-rated bespoke bakery nestled in Otley, creating exquisite custom cakes for memorable occasions. With a perfect 5 out of 5-star rating from delighted customers, this bakery has established itself as a go-to for truly special celebratory treats. From elaborate wedding creations to personalised birthday masterpieces, the team at Polly's Cakes prides itself on delivering edible artistry.

The bakery specialises in crafting unique, made-to-order cakes that not only look incredible but taste divine. Customers consistently praise the team's ability to interpret specific requests, whether it's recreating a magnificent castle for a wedding or capturing an artist's essence for a milestone birthday. Each cake is a testament to meticulous attention to detail and a passion for baking, leaving recipients 'over the moon' and even 'in tears' of joy over their beautiful and delicious creations.

Visiting Information

Polly's Cakes operates Monday to Friday, from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, offering convenient weekday appointments for consultations and cake collections. Please note the bakery is closed on weekends. Specific details regarding accessibility features and payment options are not publicly provided.

5.0

from 5 reviews

Google Reviews

Reviews from Google Maps.

Reviews sourced from Google Maps.Last updated 6 February 2026.

Anonymous

5/5

9 months ago

We cannot recommend Polly's cakes highly enough! For our wedding at the stunning Hazlewood Castle, Polly created the most incredible red velvet wedding cake – not just delicious, but a true showstopper. We had requested a castle-shaped cake, and Polly went above and beyond by recreating Hazlewood Castle itself in cake form, complete with breathtaking attention to detail that left everyone speechless. The cake tasted every bit as good as it looked – rich, moist, and absolutely delicious. Polly was a dream to work with from start to finish: responsive, creative, and genuinely invested in making our day special. The pricing was more than reasonable for such a bespoke masterpiece, and the customer service was impeccable throughout. Our wedding was made even more memorable thanks to Polly’s stunning creation. It truly set our day apart, and so many of our guests commented on how unique and amazing the cake was. Thank you, Polly, for making something so beautiful and unforgettable!

Anonymous

5/5

a year ago

Big shout out to this lovely lady for the fabulous cake made for my parents 70th (platinum) wedding anniversary. My mum was in tears over it. If you want something special and specific Pollys Cakes can be highly recommended. Wyn Oldfield

Anonymous

5/5

2 years ago

Made a cake for my dad's 70th birthday, she was only given the prompt of an artist and she created something so beautiful and was spot on. Made my dad super happy and over the moon with it. Can't recommend enough.

Anonymous

5/5

a year ago

Our Wedding Cake & Honey bee & butterfly cupcakes were perfect for the rustic theme of our Wedding last week. They were beautifuly light & sweet & had many compliments from our guests. Would definitely recommend this friendly & professional baker for any special occasion. Thank-you.... Liz & Clive Robinson

Anonymous

5/5

5 years ago