Goodfellas Restaurant
📍 53 Sheffield Rd, Rotherham S60 1DA, UK
About Goodfellas Restaurant
Goodfellas Restaurant, located in Rotherham, offers a highly-rated dining experience, praised by guests for its delicious cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. With an impressive Google rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 285 reviews, it's a popular choice for those seeking quality food in a cosy setting.
Visitors consistently highlight the superb quality of the food, noting that dishes are cooked to order and exceptionally tasty. The friendly and accommodating team creates a lovely, cosy atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for an office party, a romantic dinner for two, or a gathering with friends. Many loyal customers return repeatedly, commending the excellent service and overall memorable experience.
Visiting Information
Goodfellas Restaurant operates Wednesday to Saturday from 5:30 PM to 9:30 PM. The establishment is fully committed to accessibility, offering wheelchair accessible parking, entrance, restrooms, and seating. For convenience, a range of payment options are accepted, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC contactless payments.
Location
Interactive Map
View accommodation, attractions, restaurants, and events on the map
1 location
📍 53 Sheffield Rd, Rotherham S60 1DA, UK
from 285 reviews
Google Reviews
Reviews from Google Maps.
Showing 5 of 285 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 9 February 2026.
Office Christmas party. Food was delicious, lovely cosy atmosphere, very welcoming and friendly proprietors and a large, happy group of people left with full bellies. Would highly recommend.
Been a couple of times, always booked ahead, we've had a lovely warm welcome both times. The food is quality, cooked to order & delicious. Highly recommended, lovely atmosphere & great for dining with friends or as a couple.
Been multiple times now and this place is somewhere very special! Great food, Service and atmosphere! Love it and will be back again soon!!
Great place , lovely food 15/04/23...once again absolutely great!!! 27/09/25…. Had a great meal and the atmosphere is brilliant. The food was amazing and the service from Harry was first class.
A great restaurant with great quality food. Service was excellent, the restaurant is relatively small but very well laid out, the atmosphere is very friendly (family run I think), we had a romantic meal but we plan to return for a birthday celebration in a few weeks. I cant recommend Goodfella's enough, we'll return again & again