Lily's

Discover Lily's, a Sheffield baking institution renowned for its legendary crab mayo sandwiches and delectable pies.

Lily's, nestled on Penistone Road in Sheffield, is a cherished local institution with a legacy spanning over three decades. This bustling bakery is renowned for its commitment to classic, satisfying treats, earning a fantastic 4.6/5 star rating from hundreds of satisfied customers.

Visitors to Lily's can expect a vibrant atmosphere, often bustling with activity, reflecting its enduring popularity. The bakery is particularly celebrated for its generous offerings, drawing praise for its famously packed pork sandwiches, overflowing with succulent meat. Equally acclaimed are the delicious Cornish pasties, often described as some of the best in the region, alongside a tempting array of freshly baked pies and cakes.

For those seeking a taste of nostalgia, Lily's legendary crab mayo salad sandwiches continue to delight, with many loyal patrons returning after years to savour their unforgettable flavour. Whether you're grabbing a quick breakfast or a hearty lunch, Lily's delivers quality and flavour that keeps generations coming back.

Opening Hours:

Monday - Friday: 6:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Saturday: 6:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Sunday: Closed

4.6

from 538 reviews

Google Reviews

Reviews from Google Maps.

Showing 5 of 538 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 1 January 2026.View all on Google →

scott green

4/5

08/10/2025

I’ve been going to Lily’s for over 30 years, it’s one of Sheffield iconic places, Always very busy with 5/6 people serving at any one time, from Bacon & Egg sandwiches to the full list of freshly made sandwiches hot and cold I do t think I’ve ever had anything that was less than excellent, It’s a great family business and great to see the next generation of family working in the kitchen. The cakes are amazing too…. Plus Big Car Park at the back ✔️

Sue Jackson

5/5

06/12/2025

Brilliant place, pork sandwiches are packed with meat, corniah pasties are the best I've had. I've enjoyed pies and cakes and they are all beautiful, at an affordable price. Strongly recommended 👌

Christopher & Michelle Lawrence

5/5

26/11/2025

Called in for a sandwiche for the first time today. Had Large Sausage Bacon & Egg. All cooked fresh and very tasty bread. Will definitely be calling again in the near future.

Natalie Hanlon

5/5

09/12/2023

I came back to Lily's today after 25 years to see if the crab mayo salad sandwiches are as good as I remember and oh my god, they're amazing! You don't get bread cakes like this anywhere else. Worth a trip out there! Back again, 5 years later and nothing has changed. Still as amazing and this time I discovered I could also buy Bee Stings hers as well. Had the best birthday lunch 😂

Sarah

1/5

18/11/2024

I’ve been coming here for years never had a problem always been lovely . ham and cheese salad today and the ham was dry small Amounts of ham and cheese mostly salad. 2 x sandwiches and 2 x buns = £18 something not worth it at all.

View all 538 reviews on Google Maps