New York Deli

Discover New York Deli in Sheffield, renowned for its freshly prepared bagels, delicious specials, and friendly service.

New York Deli is a highly-rated delicatessen situated in Sheffield's Commonside, offering a tempting array of freshly prepared meals and treats. With an impressive Google rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars from 61 reviews, it's a popular spot for locals and visitors seeking quality and flavour.

Patrons consistently praise the deli for its delicious and freshly made food, often highlighting favourites like their excellent BLT bagels and exciting daily specials. The team is celebrated for being friendly, accommodating, and always ready to offer a warm welcome. A standout feature is their commitment to catering for dietary needs, with gluten-free bread and bagels available, and even hash browns cooked in a separate fryer to prevent cross-contamination, ensuring a delightful experience for all.

Visiting Information

New York Deli is open Tuesday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM, closed on Mondays and Sundays. While specific accessibility features were not provided, the deli accepts a range of convenient payment options, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

4.8

from 61 reviews

Google Reviews

Reviews from Google Maps.

Showing 5 of 61 reviews from Google Maps.Last updated 7 February 2026.

Anonymous

5/5

2 months ago

The food is always lovely and freshly prepared. Staff are always so friendly. Always some delicious new specials on offer. Top notch!

Anonymous

5/5

11 months ago

We’ve just moved to Walkley. My partner is Gluten Free and we thought we’d ask if they have anything. We were pleasantly surprised to hear they had GF bread and bagels… even the hash browns are cooked in a separate fryer! The team were so lovely and accommodating. They should sing about this more as my partner was ecstatic. The food is delicious. This is going to be a regular for us!

Anonymous

5/5

2 months ago

My go to for BLT bagel. 💯 every time 10/10. Great friendly service. Be back soon.

Anonymous

5/5

4 years ago

Food is freshly made in front of you, fresh cakes and buns every day. And the staff are very helpful and friendly.

Anonymous

5/5

6 months ago

I called into New York deli this morning for a salmon and cream cheese bagel and it was beautiful, the loaded fries are to die for & the sweet treats just finish it off 😍 everything is great from food to customer service, defiantly will be back for more.